RD vs SIP – Which One is the Better Option?

SIPs (Systematic Investment Plans) and RDs (Recurring Deposits) are two popular ways through which people in India save a fixed amount of money every month. They’re simple, help build a habit of saving and are great for anyone who wants to grow their money slowly and steadily.  

Although they may appear similar, SIPs and RDs function differently and serve distinct purposes. Read on to know what they are, how they work and how they are different from each other.

Understanding RD and SIP

RD and SIP are 2 preferred ways to grow your savings. Let’s break them down to understand how each works and which one suits you better:

Recurring Deposit (RD):

Banks and post offices offer RDs, or Recurring Deposits, where you deposit a fixed amount every month for a chosen period. It’s a low-risk and steady way to save, especially if you prefer guaranteed returns. The interest rate is fixed when you start and gets added to your savings every 3 months, helping your money grow safely over time.

Systematic Investment Plan (SIP):

A SIP or Systematic Investment Plan is an easy way to start investing in mutual funds. You invest a fixed amount every month and over time, your money grows. It uses the power of compounding, which simply means you buy more units when prices are low and fewer when they’re high. Since SIPs are linked to the market, there is a bit of risk involved, but if you stay invested for the long term, the returns can be quite rewarding.

Key Differences Between RD and SIP

Here’s a quick comparison between SIPs and RDs to help you understand on what basis they both differ from each other:

Feature	SIP (Systematic Investment Plan)	RD (Recurring Deposit)
Risk	Market-linked, moderate to high	Risk-free
Returns	Varies (8–15% historically)	Fixed (5–7% depending on the bank)
Liquidity	High (can be withdrawn anytime with NAV loss)	Low (premature withdrawal attracts a penalty)
Tenure	Flexible	Fixed (6 months to 10 years)
Investment Type	Mutual Funds (Equity/Debt/Hybrid)	Bank deposit
Taxation	LTCG or STCG, based on fund type	Interest is taxed as per the income slab
Ideal For	Long-term wealth creation	Short-term financial goals
Inflation Protection	Yes	No

RD vs SIP Formula: How Returns Are Calculated?

Understanding how returns are calculated in both options can offer deeper insights into the RD vs SIP formula difference.

• RD Formula: M = R × (n(n+1)/2) × (i/400)

Where:
M = Maturity amount, R = Monthly investment, n = number of months, i = annual interest rate

• SIP Formula:
  FV = P × [((1 + r)^n – 1) / r] × (1 + r)
  Where:
  FV = Future value, P = SIP amount, r = periodic rate of return, n = number of periods

Due to compounding frequency and market exposure, SIPs often outperform RDs in the long run, despite the simplicity and safety offered by RDs.

SIP vs RD: Which One Should You Choose?

The classic SIP or RD which is better debate boils down to your financial goals, risk appetite and investment horizon.

• Choose SIP if: You desire your money to increase rapidly over time and are at ease with market swings.  SIPs are perfect for achieving objectives, including home ownership, higher education and retirement.
  
• Choose RD if: You prefer stable returns and have short-term goals such as saving for a vacation, a gadget, or emergency funds. It’s perfect for conservative investors.

Summing Up 

Certain factors are looked at before choosing between a recurring deposit (RD) and a systematic investment plan (SIP).  First of all, you should focus on what suits you best and how much risk you are comfortable with.  Before investing, people should measure how many ups and downs in the market they can handle and how much risk they plan to take. Second, time frame and financial objectives are important factors. 

Fibe helps you learn how to handle your money wisely, whether you’re aiming for long-term wealth or seeking short-term financial support. You can also book an FD on the Fibe App starting from just ₹1,000 instantly, making it a convenient and accessible option for all types of investors.

FAQs on Differences Between RD and SIP

1. Which is better, RD or SIP?

Your risk tolerance and financial objectives will determine this.  While RDs are best suited for short-term investments with assured returns, SIPs are better for building wealth over the long term.

2. What is a better option than RD?

SIPs in mutual funds are a better option than RDs if you can take moderate risk and are looking for higher returns, particularly for long-term investing.

3. Which RD is best for 1 year?

Generally speaking, banks like SBI, HDFC and ICICI offer attractive rates, though the best RD for a year differs by bank.  Checking the current RD rates is a good idea prior to making an investment.